Hard Facts about Being an African American Romance Writer

I read an article today that resonates so well with my writing journey that I have to share it, vlog it, and just sit on it for a moment.

It’s a #Longread from the Guardian title “Fifty Shade of White: the long fight against racism in romance novels“. The writer of this piece, Lois Beckett, dives right into the past and current issues with romance writers of color; it’s hard to break through when the industry is slow to see that change it needs.

As it stands, when it comes to the Rita Award, one of the most prestigious awards in the romance industry given by RWA (Romance Writers of America), there has never been a black winner, like ever. The first official RWA meeting occurred Dec. 1980 – yep not one winner for the past 40 years. But to be honest, as a black woman, I’m not shocked. I grew up watching black romance books being separated from all the others to fall into an Urban Romance category. Segregation comes in many forms, and that my friend, is one of them. I remember never being able to find them, they were always tucked somewhere in the back, as if a white woman with a flowing dress falling off of her shoulders with a guy raising her leg was so much more sophisticated than a black woman’s eyes or lips.

It was then that I picked up my first Zane book and got lost between the pages. Her words reminded me that the black POV of love and lust were different but still viable for all that read it. Zane inspired me to write my own romance stories, using imagery and words that resonated with my generation and my friends. She gave me the courage to go about this writing journey in my own way.

Fast forward to now, as I continue to push my own voice through my writing and pitch an African American romance, women’s fiction, upmarket/commercial erotic fiction book (it may fall into to some other categories but I didn’t want to go overboard), I’m wondering if there will be a delay in understanding the worth and message behind my words. My romance looks and reads differently, but it feels as good as other romance stories. Can a predominately white industry recognize its value? It’s in Beckett’s article that I find some hope that it will. I just pray that it’s sooner than later…I’m so ready to take this passion on full-time.

Here’s an excerpt from Beckett’s article:

For all this diversity of genre, the romance industry itself has remained overwhelming white, as have the industry’s most prestigious awards ceremony, the Ritas, which are presented each year by the RWA. Just like the Oscars in film, a Rita award is the highest honour a romance author can receive, and winning can mean not only higher sales, but also lasting recognition from peers. And just like the Oscars, the Ritas have become the centre of controversy over unacknowledged racism and bias in the judging process.

Last year, however, many observers felt that this was sure to change. One of the standout novels of 2017 had been Alyssa Cole’s An Extraordinary Union, an interracial romance set during the civil war. The book had already won a number of awards and made multiple best-of-the-year lists.

When the Rita awards finalists were announced in March 2018, An Extraordinary Union was nowhere to be seen. A novel rated exceptional by critics had been not even been deemed as noteworthy by an anonymous judging panel of Cole’s fellow romance writers. The books that had beat Cole as finalists in the best short historical romance category were all by white women, all but one set in 19th-century Britain, featuring white women who fall in love with aristocrats. The heroes were, respectively, one “rogue”, two dukes, two lords and an earl.

What followed, on Twitter, was an outpouring of grief and frustration from black authors and other authors of colour, describing the racism they had faced again and again in the romance industry. They talked about white editors assuming black writers were aspiring authors, even after they had published dozens of books; about white authors getting up from a table at the annual conference when a black author came to sit down; about constant questions from editors and agents about whether black or Asian or Spanish-speaking characters could really be “relatable” enough.

Then, of course, there were the readers. “People say: ‘Well, I can’t relate,’” Jenkins told NPR a few years ago, after watching white readers simply walk past her table at a book signing. “You can relate to shapeshifters, you can relate to vampires, you can relate to werewolves, but you can’t relate to a story written by and about black Americans?”

Read the full article.


3 responses to “Hard Facts about Being an African American Romance Writer”

  1. PREACH! I am a African American erotic story writer. I do it as a hobby and because I love to write. I wish I had kept all of the erotic stories that I had written. But I have a habit of getting bored after I have written a erotic story and I always delete them. I don’t think I’m serious about it. But I have kept the latest one I’ve written and posted it on my WordPress site. I love reading romance novels, in fact I love reading period. I’m a total bookworm. The problem with black romance writing is that just like in movies and television white people aren’t interested in black romance. Which is why the characters are almost always interracial. Which I am totally fed up with, why can’t a black couple be shown onscreen? If you are black and write a African American romance novel it will be put in the category of “Street Literature”. Which is story after story of gang bangers, drug dealers, prostitutes, etc etc. White people will definitely not put a black romance novel on the shelves with their Lily white romance novels. The segregation continues and I definitely agree with you and I feel your frustration and anger. Peace.

  2. I read this same article and couldn’t believe a black woman hasn’t won the RWA yet! I hope you succeed in your goals to publish your work (If you haven’t already done so). I also find that I have the same issue with finding diversity in sci-fi. Because it is predominantly white men, I rarely see sci-fi with black people or women in it, unless they are the bad guy or it’s a novel written by Octavia Butler. Anyway, I’m excited to read your work, I love romance, and would love to see your perspective on black love in fiction!

    • You are so right! Our voices and POVs are necessary to take our genres to the next level. Let’s bring it. I would love for you to indulge in my words. Patreon is a great way to check out my stories, including unpublished pieces. I hope you check me out and support and let me know how I can support you too. https://www.patreon.com/dncwrites #weallwegot are #wearemighty

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: